COVID-19 and Civil Liberties
Ensuring 'We The People' Means All Of Us
COVID-19 has presented all of us with unprecedented challenges. It is as important as ever before that We the People includes all of us. This novel coronavirus does not discriminate, and it will not be defeated without deliberate collective action.
The ACLU and COVID-19
We are monitoring the actions of Kentucky's state and local officials to ensure they are taking actions that are based in science and do not infringe on the civil rights and liberties guaranteed to all people in Kentucky. We are currently working with public officials and other advocacy groups to ensure the health, safety, and civil liberties of all, especially the most vulnerable among us. Click on the subjects below to learn more about our COVID-19 response in different issue areas.
1. COVID-19 in Kentucky Jails and Prisons
Kentucky's jails and prisons are a petri dish for COVID-19.
Incarcerated people and corrections officers have already tested positive in different jails and prisons throughout the Commonwealth. As of April 27, 2020, two Kentuckians incarcerated at the Green River Correctional Complex already lost their lives to this disease. Some facilities have acted on the recommendations of public health officials, but far too many people remain in danger.
We have called on state and local officials to take several actions, and are pleased they have adopted the following recommendations:
- Decrease arrests
- Pre-trial release (this has happened inconsistently at the local level)
- Publication of COVID-19 Testing and Isolation Data in Prisons and Jails
- Commutation of sentences for some people in state custody by Governor
- Enhanced hygiene and sanitization procedures (many incarcerated people and corrections employees are still reporting dangerous conditions)
Officials must still take more actions to protect the health and safety of all Kentuckians:
- Waive fines & fees
- Compassionate release
- Consideration of release
- Waive phone call fees during suspension of in-person visitation (incarcerated people are currently allowed only one free call per week)
- Further enhancement of hygiene & sanitization procedures
- Reduction in incarceration for probation & parole supervision
- All local officials must implement pre-trial release (these people are incarcerated only because they cannot afford to pay bail and are still presumed innocent)
- March 30, 2020: Written recommendations to public officials from ACLU-KY Smart Justice Field Organizer Amanda Hall. Read here.
March 30, 2020: Coalition letter to Governor Andy Beshear with recommendations for making jails and prisons safer for incarcerated people and corrections employees. Read here.
April 1, 2020: Letter in response to incarcerated people placed in quarantine from ACLU-KY Legal Director Corey Shapiro. Read here.
April 21, 2020: Letter to Chief Justice John Minton, Jr., of the Supreme Court of Kentucky. Justice Minton ordered the release of some of the most vulnerable incarcerated people starting April 14, 2020. We requested that he write a second order allowing this policy to apply to people who became incarcerated before April 14, 2020. These people would have been released if only they had been charged before April 14, 2020. Read here.
April 29, 2020: Open records request to learn more about COVID-19 testing and infection risk in Kentucky jails and prisons. Read here.
2. COVID-19 and Youth Detention
Kentucky's kids must be safe, no matter where they are.
Kentucky has taken steps to protect young people from COVID-19, such as closing schools, canceling events, and shifting to remote support services; however, one group has been left behind: the nearly 50,000 youth in custody in the United States.
We are calling on the Kentucky Department of Juvenile Justice to adopt the following measures:
Halt new admissions to detention and correctional facilities
Release youth from juvenile detention and correctional facilities
Ensure detained youth know have access healthcare, education, legal counsel, and unlimited free phone calls to family and support networks (visitation is suspended due to the pandemic)
Create transitional plans for youth released from custody, including youth are connected with their school district to ensure they are enrolled back into their local school/online learning
Modify rules for youth on probation to reduce incarceration, increase access to healthcare, and allow for maximum social-distancing
Expand community-based programs for youth in the justice system by investing $5 million so that they are effectively supported in their communities
Address the economic instability caused by COVID-19 by implementing a moratorium, effective immediately, on the assessment and collection of all fines and fees
March 19, 2020: Letter to Juvenile Justice Commissioner LaShana Harris with recommendations to protect youth involved in the juvenile justice system. Read here.
April 14, 2020: Letter to Juvenile Justice Commissioner LaShana Harris in response to temporary closure of the Jefferson Regional Juvenile Detention Center and the Department's response to the pandemic. Read here.
April 17, 2020: Response from Juvenile Justice Commissioner LaShana Harris. Read here.
3. Free, Fair, and Safe Elections
Kentucky's primary elections have been rescheduled to June 23, 2020, and all voters will be allowed to request a mail-in ballot.
Register to Vote and Participate in the June 23, 2020, Election:
- Register to vote at GoVoteKY.com by May 26, 2020, to cast a ballot in the primary election on June 23, 2020.
- Do you have a past felony conviction? You may be eligible to vote! Find out if you are eligible here (click on the "Check Your Status" box). Learn more about restoration of voting rights here.
- The Board of Elections is still ironing out the details for mail-in voting for the primary on June 23, 2020. We will post instructions for how to cast a ballot one they are final.
Free, Fair, and Safe Elections:
We worked closely with state elections officials and made recommendations that would allow all Kentuckians to safely and easily particiapte in the June 23, 2020, primary elections.
We are pleased that most recommendations were adopted, including provisions:
- allowing all eligible voters to cast a mail-in absentee ballot with no excuse
- offering early in-person voting before the election
- allowing elections workers to count ballots before and after the election
- providing pre-paid postage on all ballots so voters can return ballots free of charge
- ensuring all county clerks and poll workers are fully supported and staffed
- accepting all ballots that are post marked by election day
Elections officials must also take these additional actions to make the election as free, fair, and safe as possible:
- implement a robust voter education campaign so all voters know their options
- ensure appropriate health safety measures are implemented at all in-person voting locations
March 30, 2020: Letter to State Board of Elections with recommendations for a free, fair, and safe primary election. Read here.
April 2, 2020: Letter to Governor Beshear, Secretary of State Michael Adams, and State Board of Election Chair Jared Dearing with further recommendations for a free, fair, and safe primary election. Read here.
4. Abortion Care is Essential Care
Abortion remains legal in Kentucky and you can still get an abortion in Kentucky. No government should ever have the authority to force a person to remain pregnant against their will.
Abortion is essential, time-sensitive healthcare. We're staying vigilant for attempts by anti-abortion politicians to use this crisis to infringe on reproductive freedom or curtail abortion access. The national ACLU has already blocked politicians in Alabama and Ohio from using the guise of the COVID-19 crisis to prevent people from obtaining abortion care, and we are committed to preserving abortion access for all Kentuckians.
House Bill 451 / Senate Bill 9
Governor Beshear vetoed Senate Bill 9, which was passed late at night in the final three hours of the session. SB 9, the bill for the so-called “protection of infants born alive during an abortion,” was amended in the House to add the provisions of House Bill 451. HB 451 would have taken oversight of abortion providers from career health experts at the Cabinet for Health and Family Services, and permanently given it to the Office of the Attorney General. AG Cameron has made clear that if given this authority, he would shut down abortion providers during the ongoing COVID-19 state of emergency.
March 26, 2020: Lawmakers continued to advance legislation even though the Capitol was closed to the public due to the pandemic. We submitted written testimony in opposition to House Bill 451 to the Senate Judiciary Committee to defend reproductive freedom on the record. Read it here.
- March 27, 2020: Attorney General Daniel Cameron attempted to ban abortion by asking Cabinet for Health and Family Services Acting Secretary Eric Friedlander to declare Kentucky’s abortion providers are violating a ban on elective medical procedures due to the pandemic. Trusted health organizations like the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists have made clear, politicians should not push ‘COVID-19 responses that cancel or delay abortion procedures.’ It is a time-sensitive service for which a delay may increase the risks or potentially make it completely inaccessible. Everyone’s situation is different and it is critical that people be able to make their own decisions about continuing or ending a pregnancy. Read our response to AG Cameron here.
- April 2020: We encouraged ACLU-KY members and supporters to contact the Governor and urge him to veto Senate Bill 9. The Governor vetoed the bill on Friday, April 24, 2020. Lawmakers had already ended the legislative session and will not be able to override this veto. We do expect this bill to be a top priority for lawmakers next year.
April 15, 2020: We wrote to Governor Beshear urging him to veto Senate Bill 9 to protect reproductive freedom. Read here.
5. Protecting Immigrant Communities
This pandemic affects all of us, regardless of immigration status.
People and their families must feel safe to leave their homes and seek medical care, or gather the necessary supplies to keep their families safe. Racist political attacks, like lawmakers' recent attempt to pass a family separation bill, push Kentuckians of color – regardless of immigration status – into the shadows. We can only stop this pandemic if all people feel safe seeking COVID-19 testing or treatment and gathering the necessary supplies to stay healthy at home.
Officials must release people in ICE detention.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement must release all people who are detained simply because they cannot afford to pay bail or because they do not have the proper documentation. No person should remain in a detention facility if their only offense is being in Kentucky without proper documentation. ICE detains people in a Boone County facility, as well as in county jails throughout the state. This senseless detention contributes to the overcrowding in Kentucky's jails and prisons. This puts detained people, corrections and ICE employees, and the communities those employees call home at grave risk of infection.
- April 17, 2020: We sent a joint letter to the Director of Kentucky's ICE field office urging him to release people in ICE custody who are at the ICE detention facility in Boone County or held under ICE orders in any other facilities in the commonwealth. Read the letter here.
6. Contact Tracing
Contact tracing can help reduce the spread of the coronavirus, but poses threats to privacy and freedom of movement. These policies must be reviewed regularly to ensure they are as minimally restrictive and minimally invasive as possible.